• Temple EM

Development and Validation of a Risk Scoring System for Severe Acute Lower Gastrointestinal Bleedin

The Article: Development and Validation of a Risk Scoring System for Severe

Acute Lower Gastrointestinal Bleeding

Clinical Gastroenterology and Hepatology 2016

The Idea: Develop a scoring system to help predict patient outcomes and severity of lower GI bleeds (LGIB)

The Study:

  1. Derivation study:

-Retrospective analysis of 439 emergency department patients in single center in Japan

– Inclusion criteria: confirmed bleed on colonoscopy, bleeding developed outside the hospital

-Exclusion criteria: patients with upper GI bleeds, chronic LGIB, inpatient development of bleeding

  1. Validation study:

-Prospective analysis of 424 patients at same center as derivation study

-Inclusion criteria: overt GIB in emergency department, confirmed by colonoscopy as inpatient

-Exclusion criteria: inpatient development of bleed, no confirmatory studies, UGIB

Primary Outcomes: continuous LGIB in the first 24 hours, 2U PRBCs, Hct drop of  >20%

Secondary Outcomes: blood transfusion requirement, need for intervention, length of stay

The Findings:

-Derivation study developed risk scoring system: nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs use, no diarrhea, no abdominal tenderness, blood pressure of 100 mm Hg or lower, antiplatelet drugs use, albumin level less than 3.0 g/dL, disease scores of 2 or higher, and syncope (NOBLADS)

-All factors were independent correlates of severe LGIB

-Severe LGIB developed in 75.7% of patients with scores of 5 or higher compared with 2% of patients without any of the factors correlated with severe LGIB (P < .001)

-In the validation study severe LGIB developed in 35% of patients

-NOBLADS score predicted the severity of LGIB with an AUC value of 0.76

-Higher NOBLADS scores were associated with a requirement for blood transfusion, longer hospital stay, and intervention (P < .05 for trend).

The Limitations:

-Derivation/validation studies performed at single center

-May have missed small LGIB hemorrhage given small patient size

The Takeaway:

Predicting severity of LGIB and dispositioning patients appropriately can be difficult, this study found patient characteristics that seem to correlate with poor patient outcomes and more severe LGIB.


10th Floor Jones Hall

1316 W. Ontario Street

Philadelphia, PA 19140

T: 215.707.5435

F: 215.707.3494

E: TUHEMResidency@gmail.com